Costco Pomegranate Juice - Kirkland vs POM - Who Wins?

Costco-Pomegranate-Juice

Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice at Costco

Costco sells its Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice for $6.79. I found the pomegranate juice in the frozen food aisles near the other beverages such as the dragon fruit juice, acai juice, and the kombucha. 

 

Further down in the article, I will take a look at the Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice and how it compares to POM Wonderful’s. 

Pomegranate-Juice-from-Costco

Costco’s Pomegranate Juice is sold in a 64-ounce bottle and contains 100% pomegranate juice from concentrate.

Why Drink Pomegranate Juice?

Pomegranate juice is made from the delicious pomegranate plant and are packed with nutrients and antioxidants. In addition to its great taste, pomegranate juice has many health benefits.  

Pomegranate-Juice-Ingredients-Costco

Studies have also shown that pomegranates may help reduce inflammation, have anti-cancer properties, and offer heart health benefits. Pomegranate juice is a great juice to drink for some secondary health benefits.

Kirkland Signature Replacing Pom Wonderful

The most prominent brand of pomegranate juice is made by a company called POM Wonderful. POM Wonderful used to be sold at Costco but has since been replaced with the Kirkland Signature version. 

User Thoughts on The Switch To Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice

Usually, the Kirkland Signature product version is well received, but there have been some complaints about the KS pomegranate juice vs. the POM version. 

JC wasn’t a fan of the change “Not as much flavor. The color isn’t as dark. They need to drop this and go back to Pom. Costco does this too often with popular brands – moves them out and replaces them with a lesser Kirkland product. I won’t purchase again.”

JC-Doesnt-Like-Kirkland-Signature

Art had some strong words as well:

“As a long time consumer of Pomegranate Juice, I find Kirkland’s attempt to private label the category an utter failure. The product is very bitter and leaves one’s mouth dry with a bad aftertaste. 

Every bottle has 1/4 inch of sludge that collects at the bottom, and no matter how much you shake the bottle, it does not dissolve. 

My Costco store stopped selling the POM branded juice to force us to buy this, but we cannot buy this product. It is awful, and we go to other grocers to find POM brand even though it is more expensive.”

Art-Wants-Pom-Wonder-Pomegranate-Juice

More user thoughts on Kirkland Signature vs. POM are below. 

Costco Cost Comparison

How Much Does Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice Cost at Costco?

Costco sells the large 64-ounce (2 quart) bottle of Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice for $6.79. I was able to snag the bottle when it was on sale with a $1.50 discount bringing the price down to $5.29. 

Kirkland-Signature-Pomegranate-Juice-vs-Pom-Wonderful

At retail, the price per ounce is $0.10; when on sale, the price drops to $0.08. Costco’s price for pomegranate juice is very competitive, and it is an absolute steal when the item is discounted.

Costco Vs The Competition

Sam’s Club sells 60 ounces of POM Wonderful pomegranate juice for $9.28 or $0.15 per ounce.

Target sells a 48-ounce bottle of POM Wonderful for $9.99 or $0.20/ounce.

Costco will have by far the best price for pomegranate juice with their Kirkland Signature brand.

Kirkland Signature vs POM wonderful Pomegranate Juice

Many are Dissapointed

I received quite a few user comments/reviews on this Kirkland Signature Pomegranate juice and, in particular, how it compared to POM wonderful. 

The majority of Costco members are disappointed that Costco no longer sells POM Wonderful pomegranate juice. Here is some of what they had to say.

Bitter With a Bad Aftertaste?

A few Costco Food Database users thought that the Kirkland version of the juice was bitter and left a sour aftertaste in their mouths.

 

Mark: “A bit bitter. Not sweet at all. They must press the whole fruit but hopefully makes this a healthier drink. I use a small cup of this to down my vitamins every morning.”

Mark-Pomegranate-Juice-Review

Josh also wasn’t a fan of the bitterness. “I buy this juice all the time, but this time, I have a bottle that’s wayyy too bitter /sour. Almost like the fruit wasn’t ripe yet when they juiced them.”

Josh-Kirkland-Signature-Pomegranate-Juice-Bitter

Ron wishes for Costco to bring back POM, “I agree it is way more bitter/sour than POM. I wish they would go back to selling POM.” 

Ron-Wants-Pom-Wonderful-Back

Diluted Flavors?

Other users thought the juice lacked in flavor or was even diluted.

 

Mary: “This juice is diluted!!”

 

Raymond: “Weak diluted. I will never again say anything negative about my beloved Pom.”

Kirkland-Signature-Diluted-Pom-Juice

Mateo stated if this was his first pomegranate experience, he wouldn’t buy or try the juice again.

“Correct, I was trying to explain myself at home and was being called crazy! Thank you for the similarities in experience. This Costco brand is truly a disappointment. If it were my first choice of pomegranate juice, I would have never tried it again, this truly is diluted in which its placed in liked it looks brown compared to Pom. Brown, in my opinion, is as if the fruit is going bad based on water dilution.”

Mateo-Wouldnt-Buy-Kirkland-Signature-Pom-Juice-Again

There are Some Fans of Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice

About 20% of the reviews were positive and thought the juice was equally as good as POM’s version. For those users, the cost savings were fantastic.

Sue: “I like it just the same as POM.

Less expensive”

Crystal: “I agree this is a little bit more bitter than POM, but I also agree I feel like it might be the healthier choice. I will for sure buy again.”

Kirkland-Pom-Juice-Fans

Anna: “Loved it! I got it really cold, and it was wonderful. There was no bitterness and just enough sweetness.”

Anna-Likes-Kirkland-Signature

Controversial - Your Thoughts?

There were mixed thoughts on the Kirkland Signature pomegranate juice from the comments and reviews. Some were very unhappy with the removal of POM and forcing of the KS juice, while others were able to still enjoy the pomegranate juice. 

The decision by Costco to completely remove POM and only sell the KS version is controversial, to say the least. 

I would love to hear more feedback in the comments in regards to which pomegranate juice you prefer and your thoughts on Costco’s decision to only sell their in-store Kirkland Signature brand.

[ays_poll id=4]

Costco Pomegranate Juice - Taste Test

There is an extensive discussion in regard to the Kirkland Signature brand of pomegranate juice vs. Pom Wonderful. The user reviews are posted above. 

This portion of the review will focus solely on the Kirkland Signature Pomegranate juice. 

Pomegranate-Juice

I have never tried POM wonderful’s juice, and this will be my first pomegranate juice experience.

First Impression

Visually, the juice was a lot darker than I expected it to be. I know pomegranates as a bright pinkish-red color, so I was pretty surprised to see the juice has more of a dark brownish-red color.

Pomegranate Juice Taste

For taste, I also found the Kirkland Signature Pomegranate juice to be much more sour than I thought it would be. The juice had just a hint of sweetness, with the majority of the flavor being sourness/tartness or even a slight bitterness. 

The juice had a raspberry cranberry type of flavor profile.

Costco-Pomegranate-Juice-Kirkland-Signature

I even tried the juice in a smoothie that included Costco’s smoothie packsgreek yogurt, and chia seeds, and the tartness was still very noticeable and prevalent.
 

There is no denying how intense the tart flavor in this juice can be.

Overall Thoughts

I’m not the biggest fan of the juice; it lacks the sweetness that traditional juices have and instead is slightly bitter and harsh. 

I can understand drinking this for the health benefits, and it’s great that there are no added sugars, but it’s not my favorite for everyday consumption.

Nutritional Information and Calories

Calories in Pomegranate Juice

One serving of Kirkland Signature’s Pomegranate juice will be the standard 8 fluid ounces and will contain 160 calories. Those calories will come from 9 grams of fat, 39 grams of carbohydrates (0 grams of added sugar), and 0 grams of protein.

Costco-Pomegranate-Juice-Nutrition

There are better nutritional labels than this, but fairly standard for juices. The juice will be made purely with carbohydrates and sugars (34g), but it is great to see that there are no addtional added sugars. 

This is 100% pomegranate juice!

Costco Pomegranate Juice Review
Kirkland-Signature-Pomegranate-Juice-vs-Pom-Wonderful

Product Name: Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice

Product Description:
Price: $6.79 Retail / $5.29 Sale
Quantity: 2 Quarts (64 Ounces)
Location Within Costco: Frozen Food Area (Refrigerated)
Price Per Ounce: $0.10 / $0.80

Summary

Costco’s Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice sells for a fantastic price, but many reviewers have complained about its taste in comparison to Pom Wonderful’s pomegranate juice.

I found the juice to be lacking in sweetness and quite bitter. This may be the standard flavor profile for pomegranate juice, but it’s not my favorite.

It is the only option though that Costco sells, and the price is amazing. If you like this pomegranate juice, there is no doubt that the value is there.

Overall
8/10
8/10
  • Value - 9/10
    9/10
  • Convenience - 10/10
    10/10
  • Taste - 6/10
    6/10
  • Nutrition - 8/10
    8/10
  • CFDB Score - 7/10
    7/10

Pros

  • Great price
  • Health benefits

Cons

  • Slightly bitter tasting
.10 / .80\r\n", "image": "https://costcofdb.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Kirkland-Signature-Pomegranate-Juice-vs-Pom-Wonderful-300x225.jpg", "review": { "@type": "Review", "reviewRating": { "@type": "Rating", "ratingValue": 8, "bestRating": 10, "worstRating": 0 }, "author": { "@type": "Person", "name": "CostcoFDB" }, "reviewBody": "<span style="font-weight: 400">Costco’s Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice sells for a fantastic price, but many reviewers have complained about its taste in comparison to Pom Wonderful’s pomegranate juice.</span>\r\n\r\n<span style="font-weight: 400">I found the juice to be lacking in sweetness and quite bitter. This may be the standard flavor profile for pomegranate juice, but it's not my favorite.</span>\r\n\r\nIt is the only option though that Costco sells, and the price is amazing. If you like this pomegranate juice, there is no doubt that the value is there." } }, "reviewRating": { "@type": "Rating", "ratingValue": 8, "bestRating": 10, "worstRating": 0 }, "author": { "@type": "Person", "name": "CostcoFDB" }, "reviewBody": "<span style="font-weight: 400">Costco’s Kirkland Signature Pomegranate Juice sells for a fantastic price, but many reviewers have complained about its taste in comparison to Pom Wonderful’s pomegranate juice.</span>\r\n\r\n<span style="font-weight: 400">I found the juice to be lacking in sweetness and quite bitter. This may be the standard flavor profile for pomegranate juice, but it's not my favorite.</span>\r\n\r\nIt is the only option though that Costco sells, and the price is amazing. If you like this pomegranate juice, there is no doubt that the value is there." }

9 Comments

  1. Sherry October 19, 2022
  2. Blaine October 19, 2022
    • CostcoFDB October 20, 2022
  3. walter neff October 31, 2022
  4. Sakura November 3, 2022
  5. Rosemarie Wilson November 8, 2022
  6. midax November 17, 2022
  7. Shawn November 20, 2022
  8. Letty Alvarez November 27, 2022

Leave a Reply