Costco Mateo's Salsa - Fresh, Flavorful, but Not Spicy!

Costco-Mateos-Gourmet-Sasla
Costco Mateo's Salsa Review
Mateos-Salsa-and-Chips-from-Costco-Kirkland-Signature

Product Name: Mateo's Gourmet Salsa - Medium

Product Description:
Price: $5.99 Retail / $4.49 Sale
Quantity: 32 Ounces
Location Within Costco: Pantry and Dry Goods
Price Per Ounce: $0.19 / $0.14

Summary

Mateo’s salsa from Costco lives up to its uniquely different name. I much prefer spicy salsa, but Mateo’s won me over with its fresh flavors and addicting taste.

Goes great with chips, nachos, and even breakfast. If you don’t care for spiciness, you are going to love Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa.

Stock up when they go on sale because it is without a doubt the best salsa in this price range.

Overall
8.2/10
8.2/10
  • Value - 8/10
    8/10
  • Convenience - 10/10
    10/10
  • Taste - 7/10
    7/10
  • Nutrition - 10/10
    10/10
  • CFDB Score - 6/10
    6/10

Pros

  • Great flavors
  • Fresh tasting
  • Excellent consistency

Cons

  • Not spicy – more mild than medium

Table of Contents

Mateo’s Salsa at Costco

Costco sells a 32 ounce jar of Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa for $5.99. Mateo’s Salsa can be found in the Pantry and Dry Goods area of the store often near the other condiment or dressing options such as Kinder’s Teriyaki Sauce, or the 505 Hatch Green Chiles

Congrats to Mateo's Salsa

Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa is made in Frisco, Texas and sold at Costco’s nationwide. I’m not surprised to see them at my local Costco’s here in Texas considering that I live 10 minutes from Frisco, but I would also see it when I lived in Northern California about 10 minutes from San Francisco. This must be pretty good salsa if it’s sold in Costco’s throughout the country. 

Mateo’s calls their gourmet salsa, “uniquely different” and they are “not responsible for obsession”. The salsa is made with all natural ingredients, is gluten-free, and is of medium spice.

Mateos-Gourmet-Salsa-from-Costco

Will it Be Spicy?

One of the most important things I look for in a salsa is an adequate heat level. I like my salsa spicy, and usually most store bought brands’ “hot” or “spicy” levels just don’t do it for me.

My general rule is to knock the spice level down one notch for any store-bought salsa. A hot salsa will actually be medium, and medium will actually be mild. With Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa from Costco, my expectations are that this will be a very mild salsa. 

Fresh Whole Ingredients

What I do like about the gourmet salsa is that you can clearly see all the ingredients. Obviously there’s the tomatoes but you can also see plenty of jalapeno seeds and jalapeno pieces floating around in the salsa. 

Funny Fact: Salsa is now the number one condiment in America. Why? Because people like to say salsa.

Costco Cost Comparison - Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa

How Much is Mateo's Salsa at Costco?

Costco sells the 32 ounce jar of Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa for $5.99. The Salsa does go on sale for $4.49 which is a savings of $1.50 or 25%. 

16 ounces of Mateo’s gourmet salsa from Costco costs $3 or $0.19 an ounce at retail price. When on sale, the salsa goes for $2.25 a pound or $0.14 per ounce.

The $2.25 price is absolutely amazing and it falls into the same range as what other grocery stores sell their store brand salsa for. Tom Thumb’s 24 ounce Signature Select salsa sells for $3.49 or $0.15 an ounce. Taking the all natural, gluten-free, gourmet salsa at $0.14 an ounce is the much better option.

Mateos-Salsa-and-Chips-from-Costco-Kirkland-Signature

Costco Has the Best Price by Far!

Tom Thumb also sells Mateo’s Salsa. They sell a 16 ounce jar for $3.99 or $0.25 an ounce. This is nearly 30% more expensive per ounce than Costco’s retail price of Mateo’s salsa. It’s also about $0.50 less than Costco’s sale price. Would you pay $0.50 for double the amount of salsa?

Sam’s club seems to be discontinuing their Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa Cantina Style, but Walmart does sell 16 ounces of Mateo’s salsa for $3.79. This is right at Tom Thumb’s price and breaks down to $0.24 an ounce.

Once again, Costco does come out ahead on price and value. When Mateo’s salsa at Costco is on sale, the price is nearly the same as most store brand salsas.

Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa - Taste Test

The Salsa is not Spicy

As I mentioned before, the most important attribute of a salsa for me is going to be the spice level. I like my salsa to pack a punch, but Costco’s Mateo’s salsa does just the opposite. 

My general rule of knocking one level off the stated heat level stands true as Mateo’s salsa has very little heat if any.

Mateos-Salsa

Fresh Tasting and Delicious

While the salsa isn’t spicy, and is a sweeter salsa, it is still very very tasty. I would even say it’s one of the more flavorful store-bought salsas that I have eaten. 

The salsa tastes very fresh and even has a homemade feel. There is a lot of depth and complexity with the tomatoes, garlic, lemon, and jalapenos.

Costco-Mateos-Salsa

I Love The Texture!

My favorite aspect of Mateo’s salsa is the texture and consistency. I’m not a fan of pico de gallo or chunky salsa, and for me, Mateo’s has the perfect blend. 

It’s thick, but not too thick or chunky. The salsa goes great with breakfast burritostortilla chips or even Costco’s Multigrain Chips. We even used the salsa on a homemade nacho plate.

Costco-Mateos-Salsa-1

Overall, I have to say that I underestimated Mateo’s Gourmet salsa. I expect any good salsa to have a certain level of heat, which I knew Mateo’s would not provide, but it still wowed me with its freshness and flavor. 

Pro Tip:
Don’t dip chips directly into the salsa jar, instead, spoon it into a bowl. It will help keep the salsa fresh. 

Costco Mateo’s Salsa Nutritional Information and Ingredients

How Many Calories in Mateo's Salsa

Each serving of Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa is 2 tablespoons and contains 10 calories. Those calories are from 0 grams of fat, 2 grams of carbs, and 0 grams of protein. Because salsa only consists of vegetables, it’s typically a fairly low calorie food. 

Mateo-Salsa-Nutritional-Information

The main issue is going to be the sodium content. Each serving of 2 tablespoons contains 210 mg of sodium. This is 10% of your daily recommended value. Looking at this alone, it isn’t the worst thing in the world. 

But salsa is usually eaten with chips, on tacos, with breakfast, or with other foods that are already high in sodium. When combined with other salty foods, the 210 mg of additional sodium from Mateo’s salsa will add up quickly.

Mateo-Salsa-Ingredients

Ingredients

The ingredients of Mateo’s Salsa from Costco and most other salsas are going to be pretty simple and straightforward. This salsa includes : 

  • Tomatoes
  • Water
  • Jalapeno Peppers
  • Dehydrated Garlic
  • Salt
  • Garlic
  • Red Wine Vinegar
  • Spices
  • Lemon Juice Concentrate

These are pretty standard salsa ingredients, nothing uniquely different about these except for maybe the Red Wine Vinegar. I would also say that the salsa is missing some onions.

Final Thoughts

Mateos-Salsa-on-Nachos

Not exactly my cup of salsa, but very tasty nonetheless. The salsa is very low in spice, but very high in deliciousness and goodness. The ingredients are very fresh, the texture is spot on, and there is a slight sweetness that goes great with chips, street tacos, or other salty foods. 

If spicy salsas aren’t your thing, then Mateo’s Gourmet Salsa from Costco might be the one for you. When on sale, the price is more than right, and one of the best values for a store bought salsa.

Leave a Reply